What is collective identity. "Media simply represent collective identity, they
don’t create it.” How far do you agree with this statement?
Youth -
Collective Identity, simply put is a group that comes about because of it's members common interests and experiences. This means that the group as a whole will generally be very similar. Collective Identity can be placed upon whole social classes, age-groups as well as smaller groups of people. Collective Identity means that when people associate together they are generally seen to have the same ideals/interests, a shared identity is given to them. This can cause problems, however. Collective Identity can negatively effect some groups as the media can sometimes distort facts and figures in order to change the views of people on other groups.
Collective Identity of Youth has been a problem for many years. There have always been quite negative representations of youths. During the 1960's negative representations may have begun to surface because of the actions of 'Mods' and 'Rockers'. These were to different social groups with very different ideals and who had a fierce rivalry. After the Brighton Beach riots the medias representation of Youths in general was incredibly negative. The media showed the events of the day to be much more violent than they actually were. Both the Newspaper and Broadcasting coverage of the day painted youth in an incredibly bad light. 'The Evening Argus' published an article on the event and used descriptions of the youths such as "Grubby hoards of louts and sluts". This could be linked to Cohen's 'Moral Panic' Theory.
A more recent example of of Youth's rebellion is the London Riots in 2011. These riots were started because of a confrontation between a youth and several police officers. The media coverage of this event painted Youth in general in a bad light. The media gave youth a 'collective identity' by referring to them as one large group. All the newspapers and other media outlets mentioned the groups as 'Youths'. No specific groups were mentioned, they simply said 'Youths'. Derogatory names were used such as 'Morons' and 'Yobs'. David Gauntlett's theory says that identity is 'consciously constructed' and 'the media provides some of the tools to help construct our identities'. In this case the media put out these stories and because of the negativity of them, anyone who sees this and has no youths in their lives will form their opinions based on this. And so their opinions will be largely negative, giving youths a collective identity that gives them a negative identity.
A media text that we studied, 'Bullet Boy' (2004), gives a collective identity to youth. This is defined as a historic media text. This also conforms to Ann Gould's theory, they are sexual, and they are violent as they shoot the man's dog and they shout and threaten each other, Hebdige's theory is also evident through this film. He states that 'Youth is Fun, Youth is Trouble'. This is evident here becuase they go to a party and have a good time but then they go and confront another man with a gun. This links to hebdige's theory. They cover both sides of the theory, but never do they do both at the same time. This could show that the media is representing the youth community in London. This film is quite stereotypical of youth life in London, so it could be said that this film is representing what media has already been created.
Overall, I do not agree with this statement as I feel that media has created the collective identity of youth and is now putting it across in a way that makes it seem like they are representing it.